Wrestling National Champions and All-Americans
Dan Hodge Trophy Winner
• Nick Ackerman, 2001 (only NCAA Division III wrestler to win the award)
National Champions
• Travis Young - 1991-92, 150 pounds
• Cory Christensen - 1998, 158 pounds
• Nick Ackerman - 2001, 174 pounds
4-time All-Americans
• Travis Young (1989-92)
3-time All-Americans
• Dustin Brewer (2004-06)
• Clint Manny (2003-05)
• Gary Ridout (1988, 1990-91)
• Randy Rowray (1991-93)
2-time All-Americans
• Brett Christensen (2005-06)
• Bart George (2003-04)
• John Hatfield (1997-98)
• Jerome Stewart (1975-76)
| All-Americans (by year) | |||
| Year | Wrestler | Place | Wt. |
| 1975 | Jerome Stewart* | 3rd | 158 |
| 1976 | Jerome Stewart | 5th | 158 |
| 1982 | Mitch Anderson | 2nd | 150 |
| 1984 | Wayne Cole | 8th | Hwt |
| 1985 | Rick Rhum | 5th | Hwt |
| 1988 | Gary Ridout | 6th | 167 |
| 1989 | Travis Young | 6th | 150 |
| 1990 | Travis Young | 4th | 150 |
| Gary Ridout | 5th | 167 | |
| 1991 | Travis Young | 1st | 150 |
| Gary Ridout | 6th | 167 | |
| Randy Rowray | 8th | 118 | |
| 1992 | Travis Young | 1st | 150 |
| Randy Rowray | 5th | 118 | |
| Brad Henry | 6th | Hwt | |
| 1993 | Don Finch | 2nd | Hwt |
| Randy Rowray | 8th | 118 | |
| 1997 | Jeremy Whalen | 6th | Hwt |
| John Hatfield | 8th | 134 | |
| Garth McGraw | 8th | 190 | |
| 1998 | Cory Christensen | 1st | 158 |
| John Hatfield | 5th | 134 | |
| Britt Marolf | 7th | 118 | |
| 1999 | Matt Young | 3rd | 142 |
| 2001 | Nick Ackerman | 1st | 174 |
| 2003 | Clint Manny | 4th | 149 |
| Bart George | 7th | 197 | |
| 2004 | Clint Manny | 2nd | 149 |
| Dustin Brewer | 3rd | 125 | |
| Quentin Christensen | 7th | 133 | |
| Bart George | 8th | 197 | |
| 2005 | Clint Manny | 2nd | 149 |
| Dustin Brewer | 4th | 141 | |
| Brett Christensen | 6th | Hwt | |
| 2006 | Dustin Brewer | 2nd | 141 |
| Brett Christensen | 6th | Hwt | |
| 2021 | Dylan McChesney# | 5th | 125 |
*NAIA
#NWCA All-American (NCAA Championships were cancelled due to COVID-19)
- All-Americans determined by placing at National Championship
