Academic All-Americans
CSC (formerly CoSIDA) ACADEMIC ALL-AMERICAN OF THE YEAR
1998 — Kelly Schade, Softball
1999 — Kelly Schade, Softball
2017 — Garrett Pochop, Men's Soccer
2021 — Jenna Taylor, Women's Basketball
2022 — Jenna Taylor, Women's Basketball
CSC (formerly CoSIDA) ACADEMIC ALL-AMERICANS
| Year | Athlete | Sport | Team |
| 1990 | Amy Hudek | Women’s Track and Field | First |
| 1990 | Michelle Bottorff | Softball | Third |
| 1990 | Janel Yilek | Softball | Third |
| 1991 | Tina Atchley | Women's Cross Country/Track and Field | First |
| 1991 | Kevin Burns | Baseball | Second |
| 1991 | Melissa Mellecker | Volleyball | Second |
| 1992 | Michelle Mackie | Women’s Basketball | First |
| 1992 | Melissa Mellecker | Women’s Track and Field | First |
| 1992 | Marek Wensel | Men’s Track and Field | Third |
| 1995 | Tracey Voss | Women’s Golf | First |
| 1995 | David Otte | Men’s Basketball | Second |
| 1996 | Chris Willeman | Men's Cross Country | First |
| 1996 | Tracey Voss | Women’s Golf | First |
| 1996 | Chris Willeman | Men’s Track and Field | First |
| 1996 | April Erickson | Women’s Tennis | Second |
| 1997 | Kelly Schade | Softball | Second |
| 1998 | Kelly Schade | Softball | First |
| 1998 | Guy Leman | Football | First |
| 1999 | Kelly Schade | Softball | First |
| 2000 | Brian Mann | Men's Soccer | Third |
| 2001 | Brian Mann | Men’s Soccer | Third |
| 2002 | Brian Mann | Men’s Soccer | Second |
| 2002 | Jesse Harris | Men’s Basketball | First |
| 2003 | Erin Goettl | Women’s Soccer | Second |
| 2003 | Jesse Harris | Men’s Basketball | First |
| 2004 | Kate Brandt | Softball | Second |
| 2005 | Kate Brandt | Softball | First |
| 2010 | Andrew Dau | Men’s Basketball | Third |
| 2010 | Lauren Bucklin | Women’s Track and Field | First |
| 2012 | Mark Cronin | Football | Second |
| 2013 | Kate Nielsen | Women's Basketball | First |
| 2014 | Louis Joslyn | Men's Soccer | Second |
| 2014 | Alex Severn | Football | Second |
| 2015 | Louis Joslyn | Men's Soccer | First |
| 2015 | Jordan Beem | Football | Second |
| 2016 | Garrett Pochop | Men's Soccer | First |
| 2017 | Nick Joslyn | Men's Soccer | First |
| 2017 | Garrett Pochop | Men's Soccer | First |
| 2017 | Jake Stearns | Football | Second |
| 2018 | Ashley Allen | Softball | Second |
| 2018 | Nathan Hawkins | Football | Second |
| 2019 | Conor Riordan | Men's Basketball | Second |
| 2019 | Jenna Taylor | Women's Basketball | Second |
| 2020 | Conor Riordan | Men's Basketball | First |
| 2020 | Truman Schmitt | Baseball | Second |
| 2020 | Ian Dean | Men's Soccer | Third |
| 2020 | Mason Spree | Football | Second |
| 2021 | Jenna Taylor | Women's Basketball | First |
| 2021 | Ian Dean | Men's Soccer | Second |
| 2022 | Jenna Taylor | Women's Basketball | First |
| 2022 | Reed Worth | Football | Second |
| 2023 | Maddie Luderman | Softball | First |
| 2023 | Spencer Moon | Men's Track and Field/Cross Country | Third |
| 2023 | Reed Worth | Football | Second |
| 2024 | Spencer Moon | Men's Track and Field/Cross Country | First |
| 2024 | Max Cleveland | Men's Track and Field | Second |
| 2025 | Megan Heidelbauer | Softball | First |
| 2025 | Ashlyn Steen | Softball | First |
NCAA POSTGRADUATE SCHOLARSHIP WINNERS
| Year | Athlete | Sport |
| 1971 | Rich Clogg | Football |
| 1974 | Hugh Lickiss | Football |
| 1980 | John Hines | Men’s Basketball |
| 1985 | Danny Bauer | Cross Country/Track |
| 1989 | Lynn Shull | Cross Country/Track |
| 1990 | Ian Grover | Football |
| 1992 | Melissa Mellecker | Volleyball/Track |
| 1994 | Chad Earwood | Football |
| 1995 | David Otte | Men’s Basketball |
| 1996 | Leah Willenborg | Women’s Golf |
| 2000 | Hannah Willenborg | Women’s Golf |
| 2003 | Jesse Harris | Men’s Basketball |
| 2007 | Tiffany Everding | Volleyball |
| 2015 | Louis Joslyn | Men's Soccer |
| 2017 | Nick Joslyn | Men's Soccer |
| 2023 | Marissa Salber | Volleyball |
IIAC MALE SCHOLAR ATHLETE OF THE YEAR
2002-03 - Jesse Harris, men's basketball
JOANNA OLSON A-R-C FEMALE SCHOLAR ATHLETE OF THE YEAR
2022-23 - Marissa Salber, women's volleyball
DIVISION III COMMISSIONER'S ASSOCIATION (DIIICA) MALE STUDENT-ATHLETE OF THE YEAR
2023-24 - Max Cleveland, men's track and field
