MULTI-TIME ALL-AMERICANS
Kip Janvrin - 10x (2 indoor, 8 outdoor from 1986-88)
Mike Godbout - 6x (3 indoor, 3 outdoor from 1989-91)
Mike Kelly - 5x (2 indoor, 3 outdoor from 1990-91)
Kirk Pederson - 5x (1 indoor, 4 outdoor from 1983-85)
Matt Chance - 3x (1 indoor, 2 outdoor from 1995-96)
Marek Wensel - 3x (3 outdoor from 1991-92)
Lonnie Balmer - 3x (3 outdoor from 1991-92)
Brenton Shavers - 3x (1 indoor, 2 outdoor from 1989-90)
Jeff Nielson - 3x (3 outdoor from 1981-83)
Dylan Kalinay - 2x (1 indoor, 1 outdoor from 2016-18)
Jordan Coughenour - 2x (1 indoor, 1 outdoor from 2017)
Chip Brundage - 2x (2 outdoor from 1997-98)
Damon Youmans - 2x (2 outdoor from 1995-96)
Chris Lindsley - 2x (1 indoor, 1 outdoor from 1990)
Greg Cox - 2x (2 outdoor from 1989-90)
Rex Van Buskirk - 2x (2 outdoor from 1988-89)
Mike Finneran - 2x (2 outdoor from 1983)
Wes Boehm - 2x (2 outdoor from 1981-83)
Dave Van Sickle - 2x (2 outdoor from 1981-82)
Rich Van Pelt - 2x (2 outdoor from 1981)
Brent Hennessy - 2x (2 outdoor from 1979-81)
Indoor All-Americans
| Year | Name | Event | Place |
| 1985 | Danny Bauer | 5,000 meters | 1st |
| Kirk Pederson | 800 meters | 1st | |
| 1986 | Jerry Daniels | Long jump | 5th |
| 1988 | Kip Janvrin | Pole vault | 5th |
| Kip Janvrin | Pole vault | 4th | |
| 1989 | Mike Godbout | 55 hurdles | 4th |
| 1990 | Mike Godbout | 55 hurdles | 4th |
| Mike Kelly | 4x400 relay | 5th | |
| Chris Lindsley | 4x400 relay | 5th | |
| Brenton Shavers | 4x400 relay | 5th | |
| Marcel Wensel | 4x400 relay | 5th | |
| 1991 | Mike Kelly | 400 meters | 5th |
| Mike Godbout | 55 hurdles | 5th | |
| 1996 | Matt Chance | 5,000 meters | 5th |
| 2002 | Lucas Carder | High jump | 8th |
| 2017 | Jordan Coughenour | 4x400 relay | 7th |
| Travis Tupper | 4x400 relay | 7th | |
| Chase Wetterling | 4x400 relay | 7th | |
| Kirk Wicks | 4x400 relay | 7th | |
| 2018 | Dylan Kalinay | 60 hurdles | 3rd |
Outdoor All-Americans
| Year | Name | Event | Place |
| 1979 | Brent Hennessy | Discus | 2nd |
| 1980 | Charles Fingers | 100 meters | 6th |
| 1981 | Wes Boehm | 4x400 relay | 6th |
| Jeff Nielson | 4x400 relay | 6th | |
| Rich Van Pelt | 4x400 relay | 6th | |
| Dave Van Sickle | 4x400 relay | 6th | |
| Brent Hennessy | Discus | 1st | |
| Rich Van Pelt | 400 hurdles | 6th | |
| 1982 | Dave Van Sickle | 800 meters | 6th |
| 1983 | Wes Boehm | 4x400 relay | 5th |
| Mike Finneran | 4x400 relay | 5th | |
| Jeff Nielson | 4x400 relay | 5th | |
| Kirk Pederson | 4x400 relay | 5th | |
| Mike Finneran | 200 meters | 5th | |
| Jeff Nielson | 100 meters | 4th | |
| Kirk Pederson | 800 meters | 6th | |
| 1984 | Kirk Pederson | 800 meters | 5th |
| 1985 | Kirk Pederson | 800 meters | 2nd |
| 1986 | Jeff Brooks | 1,500 meters | 5th |
| Kip Janvrin | Decathlon | 1st | |
| 1987 | Kip Janvrin | Decathlon | 1st |
| Kip Janvrin | Pole vault | 3rd | |
| 1988 | Kip Janvrin | Decathlon | 1st |
| Kip Janvrin | Pole vault | 1st | |
| Kip Janvrin | 400 hurdles | 1st | |
| Kip Janvrin | 110 hurdles | 6th | |
| Kip Janvrin | NCAA I pole vault | 8th | |
| Rex Van Buskirk | Decathlon | 7th | |
| 1989 | Greg Cox | Discus | 3rd |
| Mike Godbout | 110 hurdles | 8th | |
| Kent Jay | Javelin | 6th | |
| Brenton Shavers | Decathlon | 5th | |
| Rex Van Buskirk | Decathlon | 4th | |
| 1990 | Greg Cox | Discus | 8th |
| Mike Godbout | 110 hurdles | 3rd | |
| Dave Halferty | 5,000 meters | 8th | |
| Brenton Shavers | 110 hurdles | 4th | |
| Mike Kelly | 4x400 relay | 5th | |
| Rodney Liston | 4x400 relay | 5th | |
| Chris Lindsley | 4x400 relay | 5th | |
| Marcel Wensel | 4x400 relay | 5th | |
| 1991 | Lonnie Balmer | 4x400 relay | 5th |
| Wouter Hertzberger | 4x400 relay | 5th | |
| Mike Kelly | 4x400 relay | 5th | |
| Marek Wensel | 4x400 relay | 5th | |
| Mike Godbout | 110 hurdles | 3rd | |
| Mike Kelly | 400 meters | 2nd | |
| 1992 | Lonnie Balmer | 4x100 relay | 8th |
| Todd Jones | 4x100 relay | 8th | |
| Marek Wensel | 4x100 relay | 8th | |
| Damon Youmans | 4x100 relay | 8th | |
| Lonnie Balmer | 4x400 relay | 7th | |
| Harold Lunsford | 4x400 relay | 7th | |
| Marek Wensel | 4x400 relay | 7th | |
| Damon Youmans | 4x400 relay | 7th | |
| 1994 | Corey Carrell | 100 meters | 8th |
| 1995 | Matt Chance | 5,000 meters | 8th |
| Pat Camp | 400 hurdles | 6th | |
| 1996 | Matt Chance | 5,000 meters | 2nd |
| 1997 | Nick Andersen | Shot put | 4th |
| Chip Brundage | Discus | 8th | |
| 1998 | Chip Brundage | Discus | 5th |
| 2003 | Zach Allison | 400 meters | 8th |
| 2005 | Ross Parker | Shot put | 7th |
| 2012 | Ben Coy | 400 meters | 8th |
| 2013 | John Cord | Decathlon | 6th |
| 2016 | Dylan Kalinay | 110 hurdles | 8th |
| 2017 | Isaac Frazier | Decathlon | 5th |
| Jordan Coughenour | 400 hurdles | 7th | |
| 2023 | Max Cleveland | 110 hurdles | 7th |
